Rachel Maddow and Katie Couric turned a podcast taping into a schoolyard roast of Stephen Miller, cackling about the devil.
Their fans will call it sharp political analysis.
And Maddow tossed in one aside about Donald Trump that sinks her whole theory.
Katie Couric Brought the Pitchfork Jokes and Rachel Maddow Brought the Theory
Couric recently invited Maddow onto her podcast, and the new White House Chief of Staff came up fast. Couric skipped the policy questions and went straight for the horns.
She noted that a North Carolina congresswoman had picked up the nickname “Satan’s Memaw.” Then she asked, “is Stephen Miller like Satan’s grandbaby?”
Maddow nearly fell out of her chair laughing.
That’s the level of thought two of the most decorated names in television news bring to a conversation about the man running the President’s staff.
Couric kept rolling. She called Miller “the mastermind” of the administration’s immigration agenda and added, “he’s like Dr. Evil behind the scenes coming up with all this stuff and now he’s in charge. What?!”
She also claimed voters had handed down “such a repudiation of these draconian immigration policies of ICE” in the midterms.
But the exit polls tell a different story. CNN asked voters which party they trusted to handle immigration, and Republicans came out ahead, 44 percent to 41, the only issue on the board where the GOP held the edge. The war was a different matter. Democrats carried the voters who rated it a crucial factor by 46 points in that same CNN survey, and that war came straight out of the neoconservative playbook, not out of Stephen Miller’s office.
Then Maddow took the baton. She told Couric that Trump “seems most engaged and sort of only interested in talking about his renovation projects and talking about his remodeling stuff.”
And she didn’t stop at bored. Maddow called the President “narcissistic and simple-minded enough that he can’t stop himself.”
Her big conclusion came next. “I think Stephen Miller is not there to empower Donald Trump. I think Stephen Miller is there to run things himself. And I’m not sure how long Donald Trump will stand that,” Maddow said.
When Couric asked if Miller would be short-lived, Maddow hedged her bet. “I kind of do, but I don’t know,” she said.
One Aside Knocked Over Maddow’s Whole Puppet Show
But here’s where the theory falls apart.
Right in the middle of calling Trump simple-minded, Maddow borrowed a line from her MS NOW colleague Chris Hayes and said Trump “has a sort of feral intelligence.” In her telling, that instinct is “enough to know when somebody is playing him, to know when somebody is taking advantage of him, to know when somebody is being condescending to him.”
So which is it?
Either Trump is a distracted man flipping through paint swatches while a puppet master pulls the strings, or he’s a sharp operator who can smell a con artist from across the room. Maddow wants both at once, depending on which sentence she’s in.
And then she tossed a second grenade into her own argument. Maddow floated the idea that Trump made the switch because “the Susie Wiles situation was a major scandal.”
Think about that one for a second. A President who replaces his chief of staff amid a scandal and hands the job to his most loyal aide doesn’t sound like a man asleep at the wheel. He sounds like a boss cleaning house.
The Press Already Ran This Wedge Play on Steve Bannon and Elon Musk
None of this is new. The Washington press corps keeps one favorite trick in its pocket for Trump aides it can’t stand: tell the country the aide is the real President, then wait and hope Trump takes the bait.
In February 2017, Time slapped Steve Bannon on its cover under the label “The Great Manipulator” and wondered aloud whether he was the second most powerful man on the planet. The New York Times later reported that the cover still irritated Trump months afterward. Bannon was out by August.
In February 2025, Time ran the same play on Elon Musk, putting him on the cover seated behind the Resolute Desk.
When Maddow muses about how long Trump will put up with Miller, she’s reading from that same dog-eared script. Plant the seed, then cheer when a loyal aide gets shown the door.
Leon Panetta, who ran Bill Clinton’s staff and later served as Barack Obama’s CIA director and Defense Secretary, has pushed a similar warning in a separate interview, fretting that Miller will usurp Trump. Same song, different singer.
Maybe Maddow truly believes every word. She spent years telling viewers the Russia story would take Trump down, and Robert Mueller’s report never established that the Trump campaign conspired with Russia. Her crystal ball has some cracks in it.
Miller, for his part, has stuck by Trump through three presidential campaigns. He wrote speeches, served as a senior adviser for the entire first term, and ran policy as deputy chief of staff in the second. That’s a strange resume for a man supposedly scheming to steal the throne.
Katie Couric Knows All About Shielding an Aging Liberal Icon
But Couric’s sudden worry about who really calls the shots for a President carries a heavy dose of irony.
In her 2021 memoir, Going There, Couric admitted she cut remarks Ruth Bader Ginsburg made about athletes kneeling for the national anthem out of a 2016 interview. Couric wrote that she wanted to “protect” Ginsburg, whom she described as “elderly and probably didn’t fully understand the question.”
Ginsburg, for the record, had it right. Kneeling for the anthem insults every soldier who died under that flag. Couric just decided the public didn’t need to hear all of it.
Now picture that same protective instinct pointed at a sitting President. Democrat leaders and their friends in the press did exactly that for Joe Biden, swearing he was sharp as a tack until his debate meltdown in June 2024 exposed what they’d spent years managing and denying.
And Maddow’s contribution in the days after that debate? “Given who Republicans have chosen as their nominee, it’s pretty ironic that it’s Democrats who are worried about their choice of candidate,” she told viewers. She also ran through Trump’s legal troubles on air.
So a President who couldn’t finish a sentence got a pass, and a President who talks about building a ballroom earns the simple-minded label from the same anchors. The crowd now fretting over Miller showed remarkably little curiosity back then about which Biden aides were actually steering the ship.
The MAHA Whistleblower Wants Miller Holding the Holy Water
The funniest wrinkle in this whole story is who’s pinning hopes on Miller.
Calley Means, the former senior adviser to Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F Kennedy Jr, has accused Wiles of letting her old lobbying firm, Ballard Partners, steer policy and stall the Make America Healthy Again agenda. Wiles and Ballard deny the charges, and a Wiles spokesperson called them “outrageous, defamatory, and provably false.” The White House also rejected claims that outside groups shaped its decisions.
Means took to X and urged people to pray that Miller would “exorcise Susie’s culture of corruption from the admin.”
Read that again. Couric jokes that Miller comes from the devil’s family tree. The guy who blew the whistle on K Street wants him leading the exorcism.
And that tells you everything about the divide. The MAHA crowd and the America First base see Miller as the man who might finally put voters ahead of lobbyists. The cable crowd sees a cartoon villain and reaches for the laugh track.
But Democrats take the House and Senate gavels in January, and they’ll need a villain for every hearing. Miller fits the bill. Expect the subpoenas, expect the “Dr. Evil” lines to pop up in committee statements, and expect the same anchors to cheer every anonymous leak claiming Trump has soured on his chief of staff.
Stephen Miller went to work for Donald Trump in January 2016. Steve Bannon, the last aide the press crowned as the President’s puppet master, lasted about seven months in the West Wing.
Sources: Mediaite, “Katie Couric Asks Rachel Maddow if Stephen Miller Is ‘Satan’s Grandbaby’”; Mediaite, “Leon Panetta Panics Stephen Miller Will Usurp Trump as Chief of Staff”; CBS News, “Susie Wiles’ old lobbying firm, which has made $186 million under Trump, in crosshairs of MAGA feud”; Western Journal, “Former Trump Admin Adviser Alleges Susie Wiles ‘Is Executing a Systematic Strategy to Throw President Trump Under the Bus’”; NBC News; Time; BuzzFeed News, “Steve Bannon Is Out At The White House”; MediaPost, “Cover Story: ‘The Great Manipulator’”; Yahoo News, “Katie Couric Edited Out Controversial Comments By RBG On Kneeling Protests: Book”; Fox News; Variety; CNN exit polling