Cable news has been measuring the drapes for a Democrat Senate all fall.
Ohio, Alaska, and Texas all show Democrats out front. The party faithful can almost taste it.
But CNN’s own numbers man just warned them about one pattern that keeps burning the Left.
CNN’s Harry Enten Tells Democrats to Trust No One
CNN chief data analyst Harry Enten stepped up to the big board in late October and delivered a message the Democrat Party would rather not hear with the midterms closing in.
On paper, the Left has plenty to cheer. Democrat Senate candidates lead the polling averages by four points in Ohio, three in Alaska, and three in Texas. President Trump carried all three states in 2024, and he didn’t carry them by a hair.
So why the warning?
Enten went back through every election from 2018 to 2024. In the states Trump won, Republicans beat their polls by an average of 4.1 points. In the blue states, the GOP edge over the polls came to a measly 0.2 points.
“We really have not seen that Republicans outperform their polls in the blue states,” Enten said. “It’s really concentrated in the red states. We saw it in 2018, we saw it in 2020, we saw it in 2022, we saw it in 2024, as well.”
And Enten boiled his advice to Democrats down to three words. “Trust no one!”
One Small Polling Miss Flips the Whole Senate Map
Then Enten ran the math nobody in a Democrat campaign office wants to see. He took the current Senate polling averages and handed Republicans the same 4.1-point bump they have historically enjoyed in Trump country.
“Republicans would maintain control of the Senate with some room to spare, 52 to 48, because they would win in Michigan, right?” Enten said.
Under that scenario, Republicans keep Ohio. They keep Texas. They keep Alaska. And Michigan, a seat Democrats are scrambling to hold, swings into the Republican column.
Enten, to his credit, didn’t pretend to own a crystal ball. “If the polling averages end up being the result, Democrats win control of the Senate,” he said. “If we have the same average bias we’ve had in the past, well, I don’t know.”
That’s about as honest a shrug as a cable data analyst can give. But the shrug only cuts one direction. Four straight elections missed the same way in red states, and every one of those misses favored Republicans.
Enten Has Been Sounding This Alarm for Weeks
This isn’t a one-off. In late September, Enten flagged a run of strong Democrat polls in Iowa, Michigan, and Ohio, then pointed out that Republicans in all three states finished five or more points ahead of where the polls had them at the same stage of the 2024 race.
“So, if history holds in terms of the GOP outperforming their September polls, well, there’s a very, very strong chance that Republicans hold on the United States Senate, even if Democrats win in places they don’t historically win in, like Texas,” Enten said on CNN at the time.
And he circled back to the theme again in October. “I think we’ve seen this story a little bit before, and that is why this Senate map is still way too close to call, Republicans very much in the ball game,” Enten said.
Florida Atlantic University political professor Craig Agranoff backed him up in comments to Newsweek. “Democrats have a real path, but Enten is right that it is still too close to call,” Agranoff said.
To be fair to Enten, nobody can call him a Republican cheerleader. He has also floated scenarios where Democrats rack up big House gains in New York, California, and even Texas. That makes his Senate warning a lot harder for the Left to wave off as GOP spin.
Pollsters Keep Missing the Same Americans
None of this should surprise anyone who lived through 2020.
The American Association for Public Opinion Research, the polling industry’s own professional group, assembled a 19-member task force to figure out what went wrong that year. The task force concluded that the national polling error hit its highest level in 40 years. State-level polling for President, Senate, and governor posted its worst miss in at least 20 years.
National polls overstated Joe Biden’s lead by 3.9 points, according to the task force. State polls overstated it by 4.3 points.
And the report named Trump supporters who simply refused to take part in polls as one of the two most likely explanations.
Think about who hangs up on a pollster. Probably somebody who watched Big Tech bury the Hunter Biden laptop story in the weeks before the 2020 election, watched health bureaucrats padlock churches during the COVID lockdowns, and decided the folks asking the questions weren’t on his side. That’s a guess, mind you. The task force itself admitted its data on the root cause came out “unsatisfyingly inconclusive.”
But a guess backed by a decade of misses starts to look an awful lot like a pattern.
Why a Phantom Blue Wave Could Matter More Than Democrats Think
The danger of rosy polling goes well beyond bragging rights on cable panels.
Inflated numbers steer donor money, shape the network storylines, and set expectations for election night. When the polls promise a blue wave and voters deliver something else, the same media figures who sold the wave usually go hunting for someone to blame.
Millions of Americans remember how that played out after 2020. State officials and courts rewrote voting rules at the last minute under cover of COVID, private money poured into local election offices, and the press treated every question about any of it as off-limits.
And control of the Senate carries real weight for the Trump agenda. The Senate confirms every judge, every cabinet secretary, and every ambassador President Trump sends over. A Democrat majority would hold the power to bottle up those nominees for the back half of his term.
That goes a long way toward explaining why Democrats have lavished so much attention on red-state races they would have written off a few cycles ago.
Enten’s numbers guarantee nothing. Polls tighten, races shift, and a 4.1-point historical average carries no promise about any single contest.
But the man paid to read the data at the Left’s favorite cable network just told Democrats not to count their Senate seats before the votes come in. Coming from CNN, that’s quite a confession.
Sources:
Mediaite, “‘Trust No One!’ CNN Data Guru Breaks Down Why Democrats Should Be ‘Nervous’ About Retaking Senate”
Newsweek, coverage of Harry Enten’s Senate warning and comments from Craig Agranoff
PJ Media, coverage of Harry Enten’s Midwest Senate polling analysis
American Association for Public Opinion Research, Task Force on 2020 Pre-Election Polling report
Pew Research Center, interview with AAPOR task force chair Josh Clinton on 2020 polling problems
Anchorage Daily News, report on 2020 pollster performance
Mediaite via Yahoo News, Harry Enten’s House midterm analysis