ESPN let its studio shows drift into left-wing sermons, and the suits in Bristol called it smart business.
Its defenders still blame cord-cutting for every viewer who walked out the door.
And Donald Trump fired off one warning that the network brushed aside like a bad call from the booth.
A Former ESPN Star Says the Network Forgot Who Was Watching
Sean Salisbury knows exactly who ESPN left behind.
The former NFL quarterback worked 12 years at the network before walking away in 2008. He told OutKick’s Dan Zaksheske that ESPN lost track of the guy who comes home from a long shift and wants highlights and a few laughs, not another political fight.
“If I want that, I’ll get it on a different channel,” Salisbury said.
His dad worked a blue-collar job, and that shaped how Salisbury pictured the folks on the other side of the screen. A man who poured concrete all day doesn’t want a lecture served with his supper.
“We really weren’t concerned with what the color of the skin of the quarterback was because we were just talking football,” he said of his years in Bristol.
But Salisbury didn’t pretend politics never wander onto the field. He just wanted it kept in its place. “That should be the outlier, not the every single day grind,” he said.
Jemele Hill Branded a President and Kept Her Seat
That grind had a face, and plenty of fans still remember it.
In September 2017, SportsCenter co-anchor Jemele Hill went on Twitter and wrote, “Donald Trump is a white supremacist who has largely surrounded himself w/ other white supremacists.” In another post, she called the sitting President “an unfit, bigoted, incompetent moron.”
White House Press Secretary Sarah Huckabee Sanders said the remarks looked like a “fireable offense.”
ESPN didn’t fire her. The network didn’t even suspend her for it. Bristol accepted a public mea culpa and moved on, later noting that Hill “previously acknowledged letting her colleagues and company down with an impulsive tweet.”
Then she kept going. Dallas Cowboys owner Jerry Jones had taken a stand against players who disrespect the flag, a stand aimed squarely at the anthem kneeling trend that Colin Kaepernick, the malcontent who turned a moment of national unity into a sideshow, kicked off in 2016. Hill fired back with a tweet: “This play always work. Change happens when advertisers are impacted. If you feel strongly about JJ’s statement, boycott his advertisers.”
And that finally got her benched for two weeks in October 2017. Not for smearing the Commander in Chief. For poking at an NFL owner’s sponsors.
Trump didn’t need a ratings consultant to see where this was headed. “ESPN is paying a really big price for its politics (and bad programming). People are dumping it in RECORD numbers. Apologize for untruth!” he posted in September 2017. After the suspension, he added, “With Jemele Hill at the mike, it is no wonder ESPN ratings have ‘tanked,’ in fact, tanked so badly it is the talk of the industry!”
Hill left the network the following year.
Curt Schilling Found Out the Rules Only Ran One Direction
Now hold that up against Curt Schilling.
The World Series hero worked as an ESPN baseball analyst until April 2016. ESPN had already benched him once in 2015 over an earlier social media post, and in March 2016 he said on the radio that Hillary Clinton “should be buried under a jail somewhere” over her emails. Then North Carolina’s bathroom law hit the news, and Schilling weighed in on Facebook: “A man is a man no matter what they call themselves.”
ESPN fired him almost overnight. “ESPN is an inclusive company. Curt Schilling has been advised that his conduct was unacceptable and his employment with ESPN has been terminated,” the network said.
Inclusive, apparently, stopped at the guy who believes in biology.
Maybe Schilling’s earlier run-ins tipped the scales. He had a record, sure. But Hill racked up her own second strike within a month, and ESPN handed her a two-week vacation and her anchor chair back.
Bristol Panicked Over a Name and Leaned on Its Own Anchors
The double standard didn’t stop at Twitter.
In August 2017, ESPN pulled a play-by-play man named Robert Lee off the University of Virginia’s home opener against William & Mary. Lee is Asian American. Nobody watching a college football game was going to mistake him for a Confederate general. ESPN moved him anyway, to Youngstown State at Pittsburgh, “simply because of the coincidence of his name.”
“In that moment it felt right to all parties,” the network said.
Four years later, Sage Steele found out how ESPN treated an anchor who questioned a corporate mandate. On Jay Cutler’s podcast in September 2021, she talked about Disney’s COVID-19 vaccine requirement, which she had complied with to keep her job.
“I respect everyone’s decision. I really do. But to mandate it is sick, and it’s scary to me in many ways,” Steele said.
ESPN pulled her off the air and pressed her into a public apology. The network denied suspending her, but Steele sued in April 2022, settled, and walked out the door in August 2023. “Having successfully settled my case with ESPN/Disney, I have decided to leave so I can exercise my first amendment rights more freely,” she wrote. Reporter Allison Williams had already left ESPN in 2021 rather than accept the same mandate.
So one anchor called the President a white supremacist and kept working. Another defended informed consent and had to sue her own employer.
The Awards Show Kept Handing Trophies to the Wrong Crowd
ESPN’s annual ESPYs followed the same script. The network gave its Arthur Ashe Courage Award to Caitlyn Jenner in 2015.
In 2024, ESPN handed the Pat Tillman Award for Service to Prince Harry. Tillman walked away from millions in the NFL to join the Army Rangers after the September 11 attacks and died in Afghanistan in 2004. His mother, Mary Tillman, didn’t hide her feelings.
“I am shocked as to why they would select such a controversial and divisive individual to receive the award,” she said. More than 75,000 people signed a petition against the pick.
Harry did fly two tours in Afghanistan, and nobody should take that away from him. But ESPN had a whole country full of unsung veterans to choose from, and it picked the guy with the Netflix deal.
The Fans Who Changed the Channel Know Exactly Why
ESPN cut NFL analyst Ryan Clark during a round of layoffs in July 2026, telling him while he sat on the NFL Live set. OutKick described Clark as a commentator who frequently fixated on race and left-wing politics. Emmanuel Acho later credited Clark with turning the show into a “juggernaut.”
The numbers tell a different story. NFL Live averaged around 650,000 daily viewers in 2011 and 2012, before ESPN ever hired Clark, according to Zaksheske, and the Clark version never matched that.
Zaksheske worked at ESPN from 2012 to 2021, and he watched his own family’s reaction change over that stretch. In 2012, relatives told him, “You got a job at ESPN? That’s incredible!” By the time he left, he heard something else entirely. “You work at ESPN? Oh.”
That one little word carries a lot of freight.
It’s the same disease that hollowed out late-night television and turned half of Hollywood’s output into homework. Viewers over 60 grew up with Chris Berman, Dan Patrick, and Mike Tirico, guys who made you watch highlights you’d already seen twice. Salisbury still talks about Tirico calmly steering Monday Night Countdown through a dead camera while he sat there sweating bullets. Those viewers didn’t leave because they stopped loving football. They left because Bristol started treating them like the problem.
But there’s a flicker of hope. Salisbury calls College GameDay “the best studio show on the planet,” and he’s not wrong that Saturday mornings still feel like the old ESPN. Maybe one good show doesn’t make a comeback. Then again, maybe it shows the suits what actually works.
Salisbury put his finger on the trust problem. “I think sometimes we all get caught up in it, saying stuff to appease somebody else as opposed to what you actually believe, and I’m just not willing to do that,” he said. “I think it loses credibility.”
“Hopefully we can get back to where we’re actually talking sports more than we’re talking about why somebody should have voted for somebody else,” he added.
And fans would probably settle for less than that. They’d settle for one set of rules.
Somebody in Bristol made the call on Jemele Hill, and somebody made the call on Curt Schilling. Nobody at the network has ever stood in front of a camera and explained why those two calls landed so far apart.
Sources: OutKick, “Former ESPN star Sean Salisbury says political arguments wore out fans who just wanted sports”; NPR; Associated Press; Know Your Meme; iMediaEthics; KTNV; Okayplayer; Sports Illustrated; Chicago Sun-Times; Boston Globe; NESN; Fox News; CNN; Deseret News; NBC News; The Hill; Washington Examiner; Stars and Stripes; Fox 7 Austin; Front Office Sports; Field Level Media; Newscast Studio; Bleacher Report